Why Employers Should Tell Employees the Truth When Firing

Sad man holding his belongings in a box while being fired by his female boss

When an employee is terminated and seeks out legal counsel, one of the first questions they’ll need to answer is, “what reason did your employer give for firing you?” The answer to that question is what steers that rest of that legal consultation, and ultimately the decision on whether this ex-employee may have a claim against you.

For an employment law attorney, one of the best answers to that question is, “they didn’t give a reason for firing me.” 

Drumroll please: if this is the case, your disgruntled ex-employee and her attorney now get to make up their own termination story.

“My attorney told me not to give a reason.”

It is very possible that you were told by an attorney that you don’t need to give a reason for termination. If that’s the case, double-check that you were talking to someone who regularly practices employment law – not business law, not corporate law, or any other type of law. 

Employment law is its own complicated beast. You don’t go to a podiatrist for your heart issue, so don’t go to a real estate attorney for employee issues.

That being said, there are certainly lawyers who give this advice. In their mind, employees are at-will and therefore the employer doesn’t need a reason for terminating. Unless you’re in Montana, where you need “cause” to terminate, this is true. But it’s still a pretty short-sighted plan.

Click to download cedars free Hiring Guide

Treating your departing employee well means treating them with honesty and respect.

Our goal at CEDR isn’t just to tell you the law — it’s to help you follow the law in a way that also reduces your risk of any claims. The truth is, you do have a reason for terminating that employee — and CEDR members certainly know better than to terminate for an unlawful reason. So why wouldn’t you tell your departing employee your legitimate, legal, and (ideally) documented reasons for why they’re no longer a fit for your business?

It’s in your best interest to treat this departing employee with dignity and respect, just as you should while they’re working for you. Leaving them with unanswered questions about what just happened is not serving them, or you, well.

Don’t make it seem like you’re hiding something.

It’s very common for terminated employees to call up an attorney because they believe you’re required to terminate for cause. They might also be under the impression that you must give a reason for terminating them, or to at least give a certain number of warnings before termination. The attorney is going to be a bearer of bad news on those fronts, but they will assess the situation to see if you may have acted unlawfully. Not saying why the person was terminated is a big red flag to the attorney, as it suggests you were trying to hide something.

At that point, the attorney and your ex-employee are going to talk through what happened over the course of employment. They’ll be looking for anything that might be evidence that you terminated them for an unlawful reason – filing a workers’ comp claim, getting rid of the person before they could file a workers’ comp claim, raising concerns about workplace policies, complaining about a manager’s behavior, the employee needing time off for medical reasons, etc.

The lawyer may stumble upon something that has absolutely nothing to do with your reason for terminating. But, if you failed to give a reason for the termination, now the tables have turned and you’ll need to defend yourself. Part of that defense will be providing the real reason for termination, which is simply going to look suspicious since you “covered it up” in the first place.

Click to download CEDR's free exit packet for employers.

“I don’t want to hurt their feelings, so I’ll just call it a layoff.”

Another common mistake is giving a reason for termination, but not the real reason. Employers frequently want to call it a layoff rather than a termination, as it sounds a lot nicer. Unfortunately, this is evidence of you lying unless it’s a true layoff. Hint hint — lying does not look good to anyone (other than the ex-employee’s attorney).

A layoff means you have eliminated a position, meaning that there are no immediate plans to fill that position again. Think about how easy it is to disprove a layoff. The second you post a job ad, you’ve been caught in a lie.

So, here you’ve given a reason for termination, but it’s not the real reason. Which begs the question, why are you lying? What didn’t you want the employee to know? Maybe you’re covering up the fact that you don’t want to employ someone who might get pregnant, or someone of a certain age or race.

Let’s say the person you “laid off” was over 40, and you turn around and hire a 30-year-old to replace them. You’ve just handed the lawyer evidence of age discrimination. Had you simply documented their performance concerns, raised them with the employee, noted a lack of improvement, and then terminated for those performance reasons, you’d be in a lot better shape. 

You may think you’re being nice to your departing employee by not giving a reason or not giving the truthful reason for termination, but the person you’re actually being kind to is their attorney. You have gifted them a potential lawsuit simply by not owning up to the reason for your employment decision. 

 

This post authored by CEDR Compliance Director Jennie McLaughlin.

Jul 17, 2019

Friendly Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and is not intended to provide legal advice or replace individual guidance about a specific issue with an attorney or HR expert. The information on this page is general human resources guidance that is believed to be current as of the date of publication. Note that CEDR is not a law firm, and as the law is always changing, you should consult with a qualified attorney or HR expert who is familiar with all of the facts of your situation before making a decision about any human resources or employment law matter.
Related Reading
Episode 105: Artificial Intelligence and HR?!
Episode 105: Artificial Intelligence and HR?!

For this episode of What the Hell Just Happened?! Paul Edwards discusses how artificial intelligence (AI) is working its way into the world of business ownership and management with CEDR Senior Solution Center Advisor Halisi Tambuzi. Can AI be unintentionally biased? If so, how would that affect your practice? How can you prepare for a world of AI integration? Listen as Paul and Halisi analyze the risk that AI can create if used without caution, as well as how you still may be able to find ways to leverage the value of this emerging technology to streamline HR processes at your practice.

read more
Episode 104: Can I Mandate Vaccines for New Employees?
Episode 104: Can I Mandate Vaccines for New Employees?

For this episode of What the Hell Just Happened?! Paul Edwards discusses the ever-evolving world of COVID vaccine mandates with CEDR Compliance Officer Nora Gustafson, including if you, as an employer, can require your new hires to get vaccinated before starting employment with you. Are you legally allowed to make vaccination a requirement? Can you list it as a requirement in your job ad? Or, do you have to leave it all alone and hope your new hires are doing what you’d ideally like them to do? Listen as Paul and Nora analyze the risks associated with vaccine mandates and explain how to handle them in a safe and legally compliant way.

read more
Episode 103: The Half-Million-Dollar Birthday Party
Episode 103: The Half-Million-Dollar Birthday Party

For the third episode of What the Hell Just Happened? Paul Edwards has a conversation with CEDR Social Media Coordinator and Compliance Expert Ally Dagnino to discuss a common issue – mental health and other medical accommodations in the workplace. Can you choose which accommodations to implement? Will your business get in trouble if requested accommodations are not met? How do you know which ones are valid? Listen as Paul and Ally analyze the risks associated with this scenario and hash out how to handle it in a safe and legally compliant way.

read more
Share This