The Price of Non-Compliance: Can You Afford to Pay?

messy stacks of hundred dollar bills to illustrate non-compliance fines and penaltiesDotting your legal i’s and crossing your compliance t’s can feel like a hassle, but as companies across New York City are finding out, it’s better than paying penalties later. The NYC Department of Consumer Affairs has required city businesses to pay over $100,000 to employees in restitution for a swarm of paid sick leave law violations.

Some background: New York City’s paid sick leave law went into effect in 2014. It guarantees that most employees who work more than 80 hours a year receive up to 40 hours of paid sick leave.*

As paid sick leave laws continue popping up across the country (close to 40 states, cities, and counties have now implemented a paid sick leave law of some type), NYC serves as an expensive reminder that businesses need to be aware of what’s required—and put compliant policies in place immediately! New York City’s Department of Consumer Affairs was reportedly handling more than one complaint a day about paid sick leave law violations during late 2017.

Costly restitutions stretch across industries. Consider these companies’ settlements:

Veniero’s Italian Bakery:

  • Ordered to pay 49 employees $36,500 in restitution
  • Fined an additional $5,000 in penalties to the city

Healthier Imaging & Lab Inc., a health services company:

  • Ordered to pay 35 employees $17,500 in restitution
  • Fined an additional $5,000 in penalties

Pick A Bagel:

  • Ordered to pay 26 employees $13,000 in restitution
  • Fined an additional $4,000 in penalties

Orthopedic Specialists of Greater New York P.C.:

  • Ordered to pay 9 employees $4,908 in restitution
  • Fined an additional $592 in penalties

In addition to these settlements, employers had to face a wave of negative publicity as major news networks such as abc7NY reported this story. There’s nothing like a real-life example (or several!) to remind us that non-compliance comes at a cost—quite literally. Worse, a simple mistake can make it seem like you intended to avoid your legal obligations.

Here at CEDR, we have a whole team of HR experts who keep our members up to date and compliant with new and existing employment laws. Staying current with ever-changing laws can be hard work, but it’s better than the alternative.

Friendly Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and is not intended to provide legal advice or replace counsel about a specific issue with an attorney or HR expert. This material is meant to provide information that is believed to be current as of the date of this post.


* NYC employees at businesses with less than five employees may receive unpaid sick leave, and a few other special contingencies apply. Immigration status does not affect eligibility for paid or unpaid sick leave.

Leave a Reply

Please note: CEDR Solutions specializes in providing expert HR support to owners and operators of independently owned medical and dental practices.